Class blog for "The Unstable Nucleus" at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago

Saturday, November 26, 2011

Readings and resources on nuclear weapons issues

The final opinion paper for The Unstable Nucleus should be on some topic related to nuclear weapons.   While nuclear weapons policy may seem intimidating to understand, there are several hot topics in current debate that would make great subjects for an opinion piece.  Topping that list:  how should the world react to Iran's nuclear ambitions?  How should the world react to North Korea's nuclear weapons?  Should the U.S. ratify the CTBT?  (The CTBT is a great topic to choose because U.S. public opinion could make a significant difference in what happens).   Or, more generally, do you support or reject Obama's agenda for "global zero"? 


Below are a lot of resources to use for understanding nuclear policy in general, and to get started on some of the specific topics that are under discussion right now.  Of course, many other topics are possible for the final paper!  Feel free to email me if you'd like some more ideas or feedback.

U.S. Nuclear Policy - General Issues

Full Nuclear Posture Review (NPR) document representing the Obama administration's public policy on nuclear weapons (look for the link to the pdf on the right side of the page.  The "executive summary" is the short version).

Some interpretation, commentary, and critique:
Time Magazine article summarizing the key ideas of the NPR
Federation of American Scientists blog analysis (the FAS was founded by ex-Manhattan Project scientists to provide non-partisan viewpoints on security issues.  They tend to support the "global zero" agenda)
Critique from the Heritage Foundation (a conservative think-tank)

How "global zero" started to be taken seriously in the U.S.:
A famous 2007 Wall Street Journal article by four influential former statesmen that put the idea of "global zero" back into serious debate and influenced Obama's policy.
Obama's landmark speech on nuclear weapons in Prague in 2009

...And why some think it's a terrible idea:
Time Magazine opinion piece on why nuclear weapons should get a Nobel Peace Prize.
National Review opinion piece on why supporting nuclear disarmament is just naive, and another on why the disarmament agenda could have nasty unintended consequences.


Iran

You will have no trouble finding tons of material on your own (and there is more posted earlier on this blog).  A few more articles to fan the flames of this contentious debate:
A nice overview on the issue from the BBC.
Opinion piece from CNN on why an Iranian bomb would be bad news.
Opinion piece from Canada's Globe and Mail criticizing the U.S. rhetoric on Iran.
A similar piece from the Guardian UK saying that diplomacy is the way to go, not military action.
Republican presidential candidates have made this a key issue for debate.  Some news on the positions taken by Newt GingrichMichele Bachmann, and Mitt Romney.
Associated Press piece on Iran threatening to attack Turkey if attacked.

North Korea

BBC backgrounder on the stalled nuclear talks.
Sig Hecker's report on the newly revealed uranium enrichment plant in North Korea, from last year.
Article on current status of the issue and U.S. response, from the Washington Post.
Yonhap article on South Korea's cooperation with the IAEA.




CTBT (Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty)

This may not be in the news a lot right at this moment, but it's a great topic to write about because it will make a big difference to the world whether the U.S. eventually ratifies it or doesn't, and the ratification decision rests with senators (who can be influenced by public opinion).  So, here's a place where your voice could have a real influence - consider writing a letter to your senator and actually sending it!

Main webpage for the CTBTO (the organization in place to monitor for global nuclear tests if the treaty goes into force).
Background information on the political history of the CTBT in the U.S., from the Nuclear Threat Initiative (a nuclear non-proliferation organization).
Opinion piece from the LA Times supporting the CTBT.
Opinion piece from the Weekly Standard against the CTBT.



Other topics (just a few that I've noticed in the news recently)

Atlantic Monthly article on Pakistan:  are their nukes secure?
Isreal:  some recent analysis from Ha'aretz Daily of the policy of "nuclear ambiguity" and why it's here to stay.
Opinion piece in the New York Times about plans for a new plutonium facility at Los Alamos.

Friday, November 18, 2011

Supersonic missiles tested - with interesting nuclear angle...

I just heard this on NPR this evening and thought it was worth sharing.  New supersonic missile technology is being tested by the U.S.  One of the reasons claimed for wanting such technology is to create an efficient global strike mechanism for conventional weapons that isn't easily confused for nuclear missiles. 

Check out the audio clip:
http://www.npr.org/2011/11/18/142518959/army-successfully-tests-hypersonic-missile

WIPP The Real Yucca Mountain

http://www.abqjournal.com/main/2011/06/19/politics/wipp-draft-gets-ahead-of-pearces-intent.html

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

First public views of Fukushima...



Reporters (shown above in outfits designed to protect them from contamination) were recently allowed into the Fukushima reactor facilities for the first time. The New York Times has a slideshow of their trip available here.

Friday, November 11, 2011

Opinion pieces on Iran abound...

Heads up, if you're looking for topics for the final paper for this class!  A great topic would be to weigh in on how the US (or any other nation of your choice, or the UN, or the public) should react to Iran given our current knowledge of their potential nuclear weapons ambitions. 

The piece posted earlier on "Nuclear Isreal Revisited" is a strong-worded polemic against Israel and the US, and here's another from Salon arguing that the US shouldn't be too concerned about a nuclear Iran.  The Salon piece takes up the claim that "deterrence" logic doesn't work for Iran, and questions this.  On the other side of the debate, an Australian editorial proclaims a nuclear Iran to be a "grave threat." and some US politicians are calling for pre-emptive strikes on Iran.

Where do you stand?  Want to write a response to one of these?

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Next Generation Reactor


In October 2011's issue of National Geographic there was a two page spread about the next generation of nuclear reactors. This one uses graphite pellets that have uranium sprinkled throughout them. And this reactor is also billed as being "melt-down proof". But after Chernobyl, I am a little skeptical of graphite being used as a moderater in a reactor.
-Alexis

Nuclear Detonations between 1945-1998

I found this video a while ago, and while it does not take into account events after 1998 and North Korea. I think it is still a good representation of the speed and proliferation of nuclear weapons. This is not the original video but a sped up version.

-Alexis

Nuclear Isreal Revisited

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2011/11/2011111075527560230.html


Commissioning of India Kudankulam nuclear plant delayed

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-15684591

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Iran and Nukes - Yikes!

As Adam already posted, the big news story this week is a new report detailing evidence that Iran has been working on nuclear weapon designs. This is a very significant development in the world of nuclear weapons, and the US and many other nations will be scrambling to respond.

You may find lots of articles on this from your favorite news sources, but please do look up this story and read about it.  Here are a few articles from different perspectives:

CNN article
An interesting compilation of reactions, from Reuters

Analysis from the Jerusalem Post
Denunciation of the whole thing from the Tehran Times

Monday, November 7, 2011

Will Iran have Nuclear Weapon Capabiities within Months?

Western experts to Haaretz: Iran able to build nuclear bomb within months

Experts conclude nuclear weapons engineers from Russia, Pakistan and North Korea have been assisting Iranian scientists in their efforts to reach nuclear capability.



posted by Adam

Friday, November 4, 2011

West Coast Amonia Leak


Posted by Jenny Farrell

Thursday, November 3, 2011

Biofuels boom in Africa as British firms lead rush on land for plantations


Controversial fuel crops linked to rising food prices and hunger, as well as increased greenhouse gas emissions

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/may/31/biofuel-plantations-africa-british-firms


Posted by Hillary Basile

India plans 'safer' nuclear plant powered by thorium


Use of relatively low-carbon, low-radioactivity thorium instead of uranium may be breakthrough in energy generation India has announced plans for a prototype nuclear power plant that uses an innovative "safer" fuel.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/nov/01/india-thorium-nuclear-plant

Posted by Hillary Basile

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

New bursts of fission at Fukushima?

Disturbingly, it sounds as though the partially melt-down reactors at the Fukushima Dai-ichi plant in Japan have spontaneously begun fission chain reactions.  This could happen if the partially melted fuel continues to physically shift, or depending on other materials (water etc.) that may be present around the fuel.  So far, it sounds like it hasn't led to any large increases in heat or other issues, but it is a sign of the fact that more than 6 months later, these reactors are not entirely under control. 

Read more:  http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/03/world/asia/bursts-of-fission-detected-at-fukushima-reactor-in-japan.html